Home Gun News Why Americans Don’t Treat Fatal Gun Negligence as a Crime

Why Americans Don’t Treat Fatal Gun Negligence as a Crime


Kasey Wilson lives in rural Missouri. He is in his mid-twenties, married with children, and runs his own lawn care business. On October 28, 2013, as his kids played in the front yard with four-year-old Zoie Dougan, the daughter of a visiting friend, Wilson borrowed a rifle from next door, went into his backyard, closed one eye, and shot across the lawn toward a pile of trash. He didn’t realize he had shot Zoie in the head until he heard screaming. By the time she arrived at the hospital by airlift she was dead, and her mother had already asked the police to go easy on her friend. “It was an accident,” deputies report her saying.

Police who interrogated Wilson noted the recklessness that led to Dougan’s death. Even if children had not been playing outside, Wilson had fired his gun toward a highway. “If a vehicle or pedestrian were to walk or drive up [redacted road name] they could be seriously injured or killed by his carelessness,” wrote one officer in his report. Yet Wilson was never prosecuted for the shooting. Christian County prosecutor Amy Fite went so far as to redact his name from documents. Because he faced no charges, nothing prevents Wilson from owning guns. The legal system, treating Dougan’s death as a pure accident, holds no further consequences for Wilson.

Every year many gun owners, like Wilson, unintentionally cause death and injury yet face no legal consequences. In criminal and civil courts, the legal system often fails to hold negligent gun owners accountable for such harm. Gun Violence Archive, a non-profit effort that combs through more than a thousand media sources to collect information about gun violence, has verified more than 1,500 accidental shooting incidents in 2014. Data on the legal outcomes of these shootings is sketchy, but many cases of unprosecuted unintentional shootings are available—dozens from the first two months of 2014 alone remain unprosecuted.

The past decade has seen legal measures to prevent gun negligence systematically dismantled. The 2005 Protection of Legal Commerce in Arms Act statutorily inoculated gun manufacturers and dealers from most claims of negligence in gun deaths. This is even more dangerous than it may first sound. Many people unfamiliar with guns assume that they are designed with simple safeguards against unintentional shootings, but this is not always the case. Glock handguns, for example, have no external safety: If a round is chambered and the trigger is squeezed, the gun fires. As Aaron Walsh, a criminal defense attorney in Augusta, Georgia, put it, “With any other product in the world there would be no Glock company because they would be sued out of existence. You don’t have a safety? That can’t be right.”

 Because the firearms industry enjoys exceptions from normal liability, more of the burden for preventing negligence falls to gun owners. Until recently, responsible gun ownership has to some extent been enforced through gatekeeping: State laws limit who can own guns and carry them in public. But advocates for expanded gun rights have been shifting away from an older gun lobby talking point—that we should stop passing new gun control laws and simply enforce the laws we already have—and toward a strategy of dismantling existing legal safeguards. The push for “constitutional carry”—gun carrying by anyone, anywhere, with no licensing required under the pretense that this is a right granted by the Constitution—has radically loosened restrictions on who can own guns and where they may carry them. In several states people may now carry guns on college campuses. In Michigan, guns may be carried openly at K-12 schools. In Iowa, a resident may not be denied a permit to carry a gun in public based on the fact that he or she is blind. In Georgia and other states, guns may be carried in churches and bars. In six states, resident adults may carry concealed handguns with no licensing or training required. Pediatricians in Florida are legally prohibited from asking new parents if they have guns in the home.

With preventative measures falling apart, punishment seems the only remaining legal recourse for enforcing responsibility with guns. But we are not responding to negligence, even egregious negligence, as one might expect. Unintentional shootings frequently go unprosecuted because they don’t always clearly rise to the level of crimes, explained Pete Theodocion, a criminal defense attorney in Augusta, Georgia. “If we are going to take away a person’s liberty and put a person in a cage, we typically require that person to have the mindset of ‘I’m going to do harm now’ as opposed to just acting like a dumbass,” he said.

Yet some of these cases are appalling. A man in Washington practiced drawing a loaded handgun and unintentionally shot and killed his girlfriend’s daughter. A man in Florida twirled a handgun on his finger and killed a pregnant woman. A man in New Mexico handed a loaded rifle to his six-year-old daughter, who unintentionally shot her sister in the neck. None of these gun owners was prosecuted. The district attorney in the New Mexico case told the Farmington Times, “The father did not follow basic and universally accepted firearm safety rules” but “the problem is that the standard for criminal negligence is higher.”

In 2012 Moises Zambrana was trying to sell a firearm at a church in Florida. He took two men into a storage room to show them the gun, which was loaded. He unintentionally fired it, sending a bullet through the wall and striking the 20-year-old daughter of the pastor in the head. Hannah Kelley died of her injuries, but Zambrana, who had a concealed carry permit, faced no charges. He now works as an armed security guard. Without legal intervention, nothing prohibits a negligent shooter from continuing to carry guns in public. Wilson’s and Zambrana’s cases show the reluctance of some prosecutors to pursue charges against shooters who were negligent, and they seem similarly reluctant to prosecute gun owners who allow an unauthorized person, such as a child, to access a gun.

In civil law, negligence is a category of tort, or cause of harm to someone else. Crimes, on the other hand, typically require criminal intent. There are exceptions: The law has designated some kinds of unintentional harm as crimes—for example, child neglect, which society understands is a significant harm to the state that the law should forcefully deter. Specific statutes define child neglect, so prosecutors feel mandated to pursue charges against negligent parents. Few statutes define gun negligence, though, leaving more discretion to district attorneys. Where district attorneys or judges are elected, the gun lobby and local attitudes toward guns can affect whether the state wants to claim that leaving a loaded gun lying around deviates from normal, responsible behavior. “Remember, the prosecutor is elected,” said Korey Reiman, a criminal defense attorney in Lincoln, Nebraska. “If he starts ringing up people who accidentally shoot their buddy hunting, he isn’t going to be prosecuting long.”

 Gun negligence cases do not fare much better in civil courts. Such cases may seem best suited to civil cases, but civil judgments do not rescind the gun rights of negligent shooters. Also, in many unintentional shootings, the only people who could claim damages would be the gun owner himself or his family—when a preschooler gets hold of a parent’s unsecured gun and kills his sibling, the negligent parent would need to sue himself. With no criminal or civil recourse, these avoidable deaths go unaddressed by the justice system.

When a surviving family member does sue a negligent gun owner for the death of a child or spouse, their lawsuits often fail. Andrew McClurg, a law professor at the University of Memphis, has written extensively on what he sees as a “right to be negligent” that has arisen from the failure of courts to hold negligent gun owners accountable. McClurg sees these rulings as flagrant violations of tort principles that result from strange mistakes in reasoning about risk—judges have ruled in favor of negligent gun owners because specific chains of events were unforeseeable.

For example, in Strever v. Cline, the Montana Supreme Court decided that a gun owner who left a loaded handgun in an unlocked truck parked on a public street was not liable for the death of a boy killed with the gun. Four boys rummaged through the truck, left, then returned to look for things to steal. One of them found the handgun, waved it around, and unintentionally killed another boy. The court decided that it was impossible to foresee that the boys would make two trips to the truck or that one of them would wave the gun around, and so decided the gun owner was not at fault. But those details are incidental, says McClurg—we don’t need to foresee such specifics, we only need to foresee the risk of the shooting. Leaving a loaded gun in an unlocked, unattended truck is negligent because someone such as a child might access it and harm someone, and that risk of harm is exactly what panned out.

Findings in other civil cases against negligent gun owners suggest that political sensibilities motivate some decisions by the court. In one case McClurg examined, a gun owner kept a loaded handgun next to a tray of change in his bedroom, which he allowed his teenage daughter to raid for spending money. Sometimes she did this with her boyfriend; eventually, the boyfriend took the gun and used it to rob and murder a man who was leaving a restaurant. The victim’s family sued the girl’s father for leaving a loaded gun lying around where he knew minors could access it. The court declined to hold him liable, saying it was “not persuaded that society is prepared to extend the duties of gun owners that far.” This reasoning was not based on principles of liability, but on what the court thought the implications would be for gun ownership in America.

Indeed, political squeamishness about defining responsible gun ownership drives our failure to hold negligent gun owners accountable. It leads to statutes that protect recklessness among manufacturers and sellers, enables legislation that encourages gun proliferation, and shackles a legal system that ends up seeming more concerned about running afoul of the firearms lobby and its adherents than in protecting the public.

So what can we do? I asked McClurg. “That’s the million-dollar question,” he said. “The law already supports liability, so it would require a change in our mindset.”

If we want to see criminal charges more consistently brought against negligent gun owners, more specific legislation is in order. Don Kleine, the attorney for Douglas County, Nebraska, explained, “The way we file a charge is based on the laws the legislature passes. If we want to charge something, we have to have a statute somewhere. If the legislature would enact something to give us some guidance, to say, ‘This is something we feel is so inappropriate that we’re going to have a law that says that if somebody doesn’t put their gun away the right way or leaves it accessible to a child without the proper safeguards on it, then that’s a crime,’ then that would certainly help us—we have to have a law to enforce.”

Otherwise, he explained, it remains a civil issue. Without a statute, there’s no crime. With politicians as timid as prosecutors, we won’t be seeing those statutes anytime soon.





  1. I’m really loving the theme/design of your blog. Do you ever run into any web browser compatibility problems? A number of my blog readers have complained about my website not operating correctly in Explorer but looks great in Firefox. Do you have any ideas to help fix this problem?

  2. You ought to actually think about engaged on creating this blog into a significant authority on this market. You evidently have a grasp handle of the topics everyone seems to be trying to find on this website in any case and you could actually even earn a buck or two off of some advertisements. Id discover following latest subjects and raising the quantity of write ups you place up and I guarantee you’d begin seeing some amazing targeted traffic within the close to future. Only a thought, good luck in no matter you do!
    cheap belstaff sale http://www.cheapbelstaff.cc

  3. While more study is being performed to more completely understand all the benefits of All-natural Garcinia cambogia extract Extract in the body, numerous are currently seeing the amazing benefits of including Garcinia cambogia
    extract to their diet.

  4. Here are some tutorials and initiatives you can create using recycled materials or even unwanted jewelry items.

  5. I was wondering if you want to be a visitor poster on my web site? and in trade you possibly can include a hyperlink your publish? Please reply whenever you get an opportunity and I will send you my contact particulars thanks. Anyway, in my language, there usually are not much good supply like this.
    barbour jackets sale http://barbour.ttravelmint.com

  6. I’m more than happy with how they turned out and it was a very fast
    undertaking. My major buy was the glue (at Michael’s for underneath $7
    if I remember appropriately) and the buttons (price varies – could be free when you’ve got a few of your individual!) with the bracelet
    blanks (around $2).

  7. […] a cranium in black. Both the front and the again aspect of the earring has the skull. Tiny piece, Joma Jewellery a little so it will not stick out from the ear needlessly. Fashionable for all year around. If you do your […]

  8. Your blog is fine. I simply want to touch upon the design. Its too loud. Its doing approach an excessive amount of and it takes away from what youve got to say which I think is basically important. I dont know in the event you didnt suppose that your words may maintain everyones consideration, but you have been wrong. Anyway, in my language, there usually are not a lot good source like this.
    vivienne westwood online https://spectrumtraveltours.com/vivienne-westwood/

  9. I’ve been exploring for a bit for any high-quality
    articles or weblog posts on this kind of area
    . Exploring in Yahoo I finally stumbled upon this website.
    Studying this info So i am happy to exhibit that I have an incredibly good uncanny feeling I
    came upon just what I needed. I such a lot no doubt will
    make certain to don?t overlook this website and provides
    it a glance on a continuing basis.

  10. I don’t even know how I ended up here, but I thought this post was good.

    I do not know who you are but certainly you’re going to a famous blogger if you
    are not already 😉 Cheers!

  11. It’s actually very difficult in thiѕ busy life tо listen newas ߋn Television, soo I ⲟnly use web foг that purpose, and obtain the hottest news.

  12. Hеllo this iѕ kіnd оf off off topic
    but I ᴡas wanting to know if blogs uuse WYSIWYG
    edxitors οr if you havе tοo manually code ѡith HTML.
    I’m starting a blog soon Ьut have no coding knowledge
    so I ѡanted to ɡеt advice rom somеone with experience.
    Any helρ woulⅾ bee enormously appreciated!

  13. According to a police official, an Asian salesman at a gold store on the souq reported the theft of two
    rings price Dh4,000.

  14. Trying to find jewelry to your sister who’s going
    for marriage? It can want varnishing on each side, and can in all probability require 2 coats.

  15. Je vous conseille de bien choisir votre installateur et particulièrement de prendre des gens de votre région et
    dont les temps de services clients sont minimes . effectivement si tous les créateurs de
    monte escalier à la hauteur qualité se valent ( Acorn , Stannah , Thyssen .

    . ) en revanche quand vous tombez en panne et
    si vous faîtes affaire avec les sociétés nationales , il n’y a plus personne , certains attendent plus de 15J pour être dépanné ce qui est
    inadmissible pour des personnes à mobilité limitée . par ailleurs , faîtes intervenir plusieurs professionnels dans le but de confronter les devis parce que certains vous les
    mettent en vente à prix d’or . Enfin n’hésitez pas à faire des études scientifiques de faisabilité parce que
    souvent aussi certains vous mettent en vente des
    monte escaliers inutilisables au moyen de la configuration de
    votre habitation mais comme certains sont là pour prospecter
    ( des ” purs ” de commerce ) alors ils sont prêts à
    tout . Pour les monte escaliers d’occasions c’est à fuir aussi selon moi .
    . Pour répondre aussi à d’autres commentaires
    il y a des sociétés qui ont une aide 24h/24h et les contrats d’entretien ne sont pas
    nécessaires chez chaque personne . Voilà , installateur
    de monte escalier c’est un travail et par ailleurs ces derniers ont la qualité
    d’ ” artisans ” donc faîtes gare de prendre des personnes expérimentées et sincères .

  16. Dear friend. I truly just like your posting and your current web page all in all! That write-up is really plainly composed and without difficulty understandable. Your WordPress style is awesome as well! Would be awesome to discover exactly where My partner and i are able obtain this. Please hold up the very good work. We all need much more this kind of website owners just like you on the web and much less spammers. Wonderful man!
    keen shoes for men outlet http://www.keensale.online

  17. If you are purchasing a new phone for yourself, your teen, or your significant other,
    seek out a GPS-enabled model. They offer features like Two Wash
    Courses (Gentle & Normal Wash, twin water inlets, spin shower, two wash
    courses (Gentle and Normal wash), and wheels for easy mobility in some models.
    Whichever cell telephone spy plan you decide to become a
    member of they will give you a web site handle to visit to download the program.

  18. It?s hard to find well-informed people for this subject, but you seem like you know what you?re talking about!

  19. Diamonds can be found in practically every shade within the rainbow.
    The timing was excellent. We identified a space and entered the market.

  20. These colorful items weren’t meant to last for generations, and most have been manufactured from
    glass, plastic, and low cost metals.

  21. Aw, this was a very good post. Spending some time and
    actual effort to generate a really good article? but what can I say?

    I hesitate a whole lot and don’t seem to get anything done.

  22. Excellent post however , I was wondering if you could write a litte more on this
    subject? I’d be very thankful if you could elaborate a little bit more.
    Appreciate it!

  23. We arе a grouⲣ of volᥙntеers and opening a
    new scheme in our community. Your web sіte offered us with valᥙable іnfo t᧐ work on. You’ve done an impressive job and our entire community wiⅼl be
    thankful to you.

  24. Mʏ famioy members always ssay that I aam wasting my time
    herе at web, except I know I am ɡetting experience everydaу by reading thes nice articⅼes or reviews.

  25. We are referring to your base of cash flow right here.
    Whichever method you plan to use, you cannot do this on your
    own very easily; you will need some extra equipment. So if you might be questioning
    where they are really planning if you deliver them
    out on errands than the GPS feature will actually come
    in handy when monitoring them.

  26. It’s thе Ƅest time to mаke some plans for tһe future aand it’stime to be hаppy.
    I’ve rеad thius post and if I could I wіsh to suggest you ѕome interesting thins or advice.
    Pеrhaps yοu can wrіte neхt articles referring tο this article.
    I want to read more things about it!

  27. I’m not positive where you’re getting your information, but good topic.
    I needs to spend a while studying more or working out more.
    Thanks for wonderful information I was looking
    for this info for my mission.

  28. Wondеrful beat ! I ᴡisһ to apprentice at thee same time as youu аmend yoour site, hoᴡ can i sᥙbscrribe
    for a weƄlog websitе? The acount aided
    mme a applicable deal. I hhave Ьeen a little bit aⅽquainted of this your broadcast offered vibrant
    transparent іdea

  29. Established solutions relating to Smartphone Spyphone
    can be checked out on our website. For example, you maybe the boss of a company
    and suspect your employee is abusing his or her phone privileges.
    This IP address then can be mapped to general geolocation data.

  30. I tһink other wеbsite owners should take this web site
    as an model,very clean and fantastic user pleasant pattеrn.

  31. Hi therе! I could hɑve sworn Ι’ve been to your blog before but ɑfter looking at many ᧐f the postѕ I realized it’ѕ new to me.
    Nonetheless, I’m certainly pⅼeased I came across itt and I’ll be bookmaгking
    it and checking back often!

  32. If you are purchasing a new phone for yourself, your teen, or your
    significant other, seek out a GPS-enabled model.

    Some of these applications you can get as spy on mobile SMS free applications.
    Right after all, it really is your corporation that feeds and outfits your relatives and puts a ceiling over their mind.

  33. Hi – very great site you have established. I enjoyed reading this posting. I did want to publish a remark to tell you that the design of this site is very aesthetically delightful. I used to be a graphic designer, now I am a copy editor for a firm. I have always enjoyed playing with information processing systems and am attempting to learn computer code in my spare time (which there is never enough of lol).
    pierre hardy pumps http://www.pierrehardysale.cc

  34. Nice blоg! Is yoᥙr theme custom maԁe or did you download it from somewhere?
    A design like yours ѡith a few simple tweeks would really make my blog shine.
    Please let me know where you got your design. Cheers

  35. A llot of thqnkѕ for youг own еffort on this website.
    My niece really loves engaging in investigations and it iѕ easy to see
    why. Most of uss learn all cօncerning the dynamic method you produce practical tips and hints by means
    of your web site and as well cauyse гesponse from others on thaat theme while our own princess is truly
    understanding so much. Takee pleaѕure in the гemaining portion of the ʏear.
    You have Ьeen carrying օut a great jⲟb.

  36. I hɑve been ƅrowsing on-line greater than 3 hours these
    days, yet I never found any attention-grabbingarticle like yourѕ.
    It iѕ beautiful w᧐rth enough for me. Personally, if all site owners and
    blogɡers made jusdt right contet as you did, the net
    wiⅼl likely be much more һelpful than ever before.

  37. Ƭhanks foгr еvery other wonderful post. Where else may
    anybody get that kind of information in such an ideal
    apprߋach ᧐f writing? I’ve a presentation subsequent week,
    and I’m at the look for such information.

  38. Ꮋello vwry coοl Ƅlοg!! Man .. Ᏼeаutіful ..
    Sսperb .. I’lⅼ bookmarқ уour website and take the feeds also?I’m satisfied too search out numerous useful info herе in the post, we need work oᥙt extra strategies
    on this regard, thank you for sharing.

  39. I hɑve been exploring for a little for any
    high quality articles or blog posts in this sort of spɑce .
    Exploring in Yahoo I finally stumƅled upon this web site.
    Studying this information So i’m glad to convey that I have a very just right uncanny feeling I found out exactly what I needed.
    І so much surely will make sսre to don’t omit this web site and give it a ցlance on a continuing

  40. Does yoᥙr blog have a contact page? I’m having trouble locating it but,
    I’d like to shοot you an email. I’ᴠe got some recοmmendatіons
    for your blog you might be interested in hearing.
    Either way, great site and I look forward to seeing it expand over time.

  41. With this Blackberry spy software you will not be left in the dark.
    Whichever method you plan to use, you cannot do this on your own very easily; you will need some extra equipment.
    This IP address then can be mapped to general geolocation data.

  42. This could be a good way of detecting if any spy app is really present on your Android phone
    or not. They offer features like Two Wash Courses (Gentle & Normal Wash, twin water inlets,
    spin shower, two wash courses (Gentle and Normal wash), and wheels for easy
    mobility in some models. Today, I and Bianca have become
    best friends again.

  43. There are voice activated recorders, little cameras, and even GPS devices out there.

    You can use a free of charge telephone tracker app but they are really effortless to detect and do not do close to as very much as this app does.
    This IP address then can be mapped to general geolocation data.

  44. It is supposedly a short term association aimed maybe at changing existing trade bill services
    – a brief flexible measure in hope of a extra stable enterprise surroundings.
    But what occasions would cause a breach of such a banking settlement?

  45. It’s not really your cash, it stands for Curi (steal) People’s Funds, you
    will be lifeless earlier than you get to spend it,
    and many others. All the the reason why, given the opportunity, Singaporeans will
    spend as much of their CPF as possible.

  46. Ηellߋ to every body, it’s my first pay a quick visit of this website; this weƄ sitе includes amazing and truly ցood information for readers.

  47. Thank you for anotһer informative website.
    The plаce else mɑy juѕt I am getting thаt type of informаtion written in such
    an ideal means? I’ve a mission that I’m simply now running on,
    and I have been at the glance out for such inf᧐rmation.

  48. We are referring to your base of cash flow right here. This computer software installs discreetly
    and no matter who is working with the cell phone they will not detect
    the cell phone monitoring software installed. Right after all,
    it really is your corporation that feeds and outfits your relatives
    and puts a ceiling over their mind.

  49. That’s why they see no issue in staying unproductive or even with stealing from you.

    Whichever method you plan to use, you cannot do this on your own very easily; you will need some extra equipment.

    Whichever cell telephone spy plan you decide to become
    a member of they will give you a web site handle to visit to download
    the program.

  50. Ι was recommsnded this blog by means of my cousin. I’m now not sure whether օrr not this pput
    up is written via him ass no one else realize such special about my difficulty.

    You arе wonderful! Thanks!

  51. Oh my goodness! Incredible article dude! Many thanks, However I
    am going through issues with your RSS. I don’t understand why I am unable to join it.

    Is there anybody getting the same RSS issues? Anyone that knows the solution will
    you kindly respond? Thanx!!


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here